8 min read

How to Handle Unresponsive Referees in Hiring

You have found the perfect candidate. Their resume is excellent. Their interview was a success. You are ready to make an offer, but there is one problem: you are waiting on the references. You sent the emails and left the voicemails, but you hear nothing. These unresponsive referees are now the only thing standing between you and a new hire.

This situation is frustrating for everyone. You want to fill the role. The candidate wants to start their new job. When referees do not respond, the whole process stops. If you wait too long, you might lose your candidate to another company. You need a plan to manage these delays and keep your hiring on track.

How to Handle Unresponsive Referees in Hiring

Why Referees Do Not Respond

It is easy to think that a lack of response means something bad. You might worry the referee has nothing good to say. In most cases, the reason is much simpler. People are busy.

High Workload: The referee may have a full inbox and a long list of tasks. Your request is just one more thing for them to do.
Out of Office: They could be on vacation or away for work.
Forgotten Emails: Sometimes an email is opened, read, and then forgotten during a busy day.
Wrong Contact Info: The candidate may have provided an old email address or a phone number that is no longer in use.
Company Policy: Some companies have strict rules about who can give a reference. The referee might be checking with their legal team before they reply.

Understanding these reasons helps you stay professional. Most people want to help their former employees, but they need a little help to get it done.

How Silence Impacts Your Hiring Process

When you deal with unresponsive referees, the costs are high. The most obvious cost is time. Every day you wait is a day the position stays empty. This puts more stress on your current team.

Another major risk is losing the candidate. High-quality talent does not stay on the market for long. If another company moves faster, your candidate will take that offer instead. You do not want to lose a great person because of someone else’s slow response.

A slow process also looks bad for your company brand. Candidates want to work for organized businesses. If the hiring process feels slow and messy, they may think the work environment is the same. To avoid this, you must focus on faster hiring methods.

Strategies to Get a Faster Response

You do not have to sit and wait for the phone to ring. You can take action to get the answers you need.

Ask the Candidate for Help

The candidate has the most to lose if the reference is not finished. They also have the strongest relationship with the referee. If you have not heard back in two days, tell the candidate. Ask them to send a friendly message to their referee. This often works better than another email from a stranger.

Use Different Channels

If email is not working, try a different method. Some people do not check their business email often, but they always see a text message. Using a mix of email and SMS can help you reach people where they are most active.

Set Clear Deadlines

When you send a request, do not just ask for help. Tell them when you need it. A message that says "Please reply by Thursday" creates a sense of urgency. It helps the referee prioritize your request over other tasks.

The Power of Automated Reminders

Manual follow-up takes a lot of time. You have to remember who has not replied and then write a new email. This is where technology helps. Automated reminders take the work off your plate.

These systems send messages at set times if a referee has not responded. This keeps your request at the top of their inbox. Use automated follow-ups to get faster responses from busy past employers. This method is polite but persistent. It shows that the request is important without you having to spend your whole day on the phone.

To improve your workflow, you can use Refhub to streamline your evaluations and get the data you need quickly. This allows you to focus on making the right hiring decision instead of chasing people for information.

Best Practices for Reference Requests

To get the best results, you should make the process as easy as possible for the referee.

Keep it Short: Do not ask 20 questions. Stick to the most important points.
Mobile Friendly: Make sure your request is easy to read and answer on a phone.
Be Professional: Always thank the referee for their time. A polite tone goes a long way.
Verify Info Early: Double-check contact details with the candidate before you send the first request.

By following these steps, you reduce the friction that causes people to ignore your messages.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should I wait before following up with a referee? You should wait about 24 to 48 hours. If you send a request on Monday morning, a follow-up on Wednesday morning is appropriate.

Is it okay to call a referee if they do not answer my email? Yes, a phone call can be very effective. However, many people prefer digital forms because they can complete them at any time.

What if a referee refuses to respond at all? If you have tried multiple times and the candidate has also tried, ask for a different reference. It is better to move on to a new contact than to wait forever.

Do automated reminders annoy referees? Most referees find them helpful. It serves as a nudge for a task they likely intended to do but forgot about. As long as the reminders are spaced out, they are seen as professional.

Winning the Race Against Time

Speed is a major advantage in recruitment. When you handle unresponsive referees with a clear plan, you remove the roadblocks to your success. You no longer have to worry about losing candidates to faster competitors.

By using a mix of candidate help, clear communication, and smart technology, you can make your hiring process much more efficient. Silence from a referee does not have to mean the end of the road. It is just a small hurdle that you can clear with the right tools and a proactive attitude.

Get Started with Better Hiring Tools

If you are tired of waiting for replies, it is time to change your approach. Refhub provides the tools you need to manage your references without the stress. You can set up your process to handle the heavy lifting for you.

Stop letting slow responses hold back your growth. Make the move to a system that supports faster hiring and gives you the confidence to hire the best talent. Let Refhub help you get the answers you need today.

‍